|
Visit
the Southern
African Internet Portal on Corruption
(IPOC) www.ipocafrica.org |
Genuinely corrupt
relationships
Who next?
Almost every news headline since May has paraded the names of
senior leaders in public life who have, or may, or cannot, be
implicated in corruption. If Shabir Shaik is found to be
guilty will Jacob Zuma be charged? If Jacob Zuma is charged
will he be fired? If he is fired will Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka
be appointed Deputy President? If Oilgate unravels will the
(new) Deputy President be
implicated?
However, away
from the glamour of political centre stage, some remarkable
achievements have been made that provide a solid base for
future anti-corruption work. Of course some observers grope in
the dark for the 'political motives' behind recent events - a
fact that is understandable given the respect most South
Africans have for the political careers of individuals
implicated.
The evidence overwhelmingly suggests
that we have a constitutional order at work. A recent survey
(see Research &
Reform) has shown that the vast majority of South
Africans have given the state and President the thumbs up for
the Shaik prosecution and the difficult decision to release
the Deputy President (see
National Administration) following mounting
evidence in the Durban High court that he was involved in a
'generally corrupt' relationship with Shaik. Zuma now has the
opportunity to clear his name as Vusi Pikoli and the NPA have
moved to prosecute Zuma. Our democratic institutions are
tested in these political high-stakes but appear to come out
stronger for it - with integrity displayed within the
executive, the judiciary and the prosecuting authority in
handling recent events.
However, if it
ended there this could all have been neatly pigeonholed as a
political flash-in the pan. A fitting end to an internal party
struggle or maybe the result of a President purchasing
political credit before he jets off for a meeting with the G8
at the Gleneagles golf course.
Recent events
appear to underscore an increased vigour to deal with
corruption at various levels of government. Within days of
Jacob Zuma move out of the Union Buildings five of the MP's
implicated in the Travelgate scam resigned (or were fired) -
See National
Administration. At the same time Minister of
Finance Trevor Manuel and Minister of Local and Provincial
Government Sydney Mufumadi came out guns blazing over
corruption at local government level. Its time that the
spotlight comes into sharp focus on the self-proclaimed 'god
of Hillbrow' and his cohorts throughout the country (see local
government).
So what? -Is
another common refrain. Trends are not easy things to predict
however, indications are that the countries anti-corruption
agencies are proving extremely effective in netting both the
'big fish' and the 'small fry'. In April one of the biggest
corruption busts in history took place in the country. At
first we learnt that over 70,000 members of the public sought
amnesty for fraudulently accepting social welfare grants. Then
Minister of Social Development Zola Skweyiya and head of the
Special Investigations Unit Willie Hofmeyer announced that
their co-operation in cracking down on syndicates and the
possible prosecution of the over 30 000 public servants who
were found to be illegally receiving social welfare grants
(See Social Welfare and
Research & Reform). The sheer scale of this
fraud perpetrated against the countries poor (see Profile: Mr. Miki Mbali)
is shocking. Umqol'uphandle has
reported on the estimated R1,5 billion lost to corruption in
social welfare corruption in the past - but this has seriously
dented the Public Services mantra of Batho Pele. In his weekly
letter e-mail letter President Mbeki underscored this:
"In this regard we must
state the matter firmly that these are parasites who are
waging a war against the people".
Hats off to Minister Skweyiya for
tackling the issue head on with the Cobra's (the SIU) at his
side (who will receive R200 million in funding for this
exercise). However, should the names of those implicated not
be placed on a corruption register - which Treasury has
produced for corrupt businesses (see Industry)? They
should be named, shamed and excluded from work in the public
servicefor a period of time.
Meanwhile, the
list of secret donors who provide the majority of funding to
SA's political parties remains a mystery to the public.
Oilgate - the party funding scandal uncovered by the Mail
& Guardian (National
Administration) points towards the fact that while
we bolt up the front door to the corrupt 'parasites' through
laws and the work of institutions - the back door is left wide
open and thieves are cleaning out the kitchen. More on this
and a new civil society initiative to monitor party funding in
the next edition of Umqol'uphandle - SA Corruption
Briefing.
Public
Service
National
Administration Mbeki fires
Zuma
Judge Hilary
Squires' guilty ruling in the Shabir Shaik saga has left the
South African Head of State, President Thabo Mbeki, with
little choice but to exercise his constitutional prerogative
and show his former Deputy President the door. Justice Squires
had pronounced Zuma and convicted Durban businessman Schabir
Shaik as conjoined in a 'generally corrupt relationship' - a
judgment that, according to Mbeki, raised "questions of
conduct that would be inconsistent with expectations that
attend those who hold public office." This had then compelled
the President of the Republic to take drastic action and
release Zuma from his responsibilities as a deputy president
and member of the cabinet. The decision was deemed to be in
the best interests of Zuma, the government and SAs fledgling
democracy. In a speech in response to his dismissal Zuma
proclaimed respect and acceptance of the president's
pronouncement, and pledged his commitment to continue to serve
the people of South Africa in whatever capacity and role.
Full Article in
AllAfrica.com (14 June, 2005) Visit gov.za
for a full transcript of Pres. Mbeki's
speech Visit gov.za to
view Mr. Jacob Zuma's
statement
Imvume slams 'Oilgate'
loan association
Responding to
the accusation that it had funneled millions of rands of
taxpayers' money to the African National Congress (ANC),
Imvume management, an empowerment company with close ties to
the ANC, has vehemently slammed reports implicating it in
unlawful payments to relatives of the ministers of mineral and
energy affairs and of social development in December 2003. The
Imvume saga is part of a potentially huge party-funding
scandal - dubbed 'the ANC's Oilgate' - which the Mail & Guardian
unearthed in a groundbreaking investigation into
covert party-funding. The investigation essentially revealed
that PetroSA, South Africa's state oil company subsidised a
R15-million payment to the ANC by Imvume in the run-up to the
2004 general elections. The exposè led the Johannesburg High
Court to ban the newspaper from publishing the controversy.
The ban was subsequently lifted. Asserting that there is a
prima facie fraud case against Imvume over the illegal
payments by PetroSA the Freedom Front Plus (FF+) has called
for the national director of public prosecutions, Vusi Pikoli,
to investigate a fraud case against Imvume Management.
Scorpions' spokesperson Makhonkosi Nkosi has however announced
that the matter was already in the hands of the Public
Protector and advised that the FF+ should forward all the
relevant information to the ombudsman and report any concerns
about suspicious conduct to the
police.
Full Articles in The Herald (26 June
2005) and Mail &
Guardian (03 May
2005)
Business
Day (21 June 2005, 24 June 2005)
Also visit the
Mail & Guardian 'Oilgate Uncovered'
webpage
Shaiks to appeal against
sentence
Convicted on
three charges that were found to invariably involve illicit
financial dealings with former Deputy President Jacob Zuma,
and sentenced to 15 years on each of the two counts of
corruption and another three years on fraud, Durban
businessman Schabir Shaik is to seek leave to appeal against
the sentence and the array of fines imposed on his ten Nkobi
group of companies. The fines varied from R25 000 to
R1.4-million for each company and had to be paid by June 30,
2005. Shaik's hearing has been set for July 26,
2005.Full
Article in Business Day (08 June
2005)
Confusion over Mps'
Travelgate resignations
The
'resignation' of five MP's (Ruth Bengu, Mildred Mpaka, Rhoda
Joemat, Pamela Mnandi and Mavis Magazi) following their
conviction in the travelgate scandal has fuelled speculation
as to whether the MP's really resigned or 'were pushed out
following the axing of Zuma as the deputy president.' Jeremy Michael reports
that the some of the affected MP's had in fact informed The
Star that, contrary to the ANC chief whip Mbulelo Goniwe's
announcement, they had not voluntarily tendered resignations
to parliament. Goniwe had 'told the ANC's parliamentary caucus
that the five MP's, who were not present at the meeting, had
agreed to resign their seats .' Eighteen more MP's are still
awaiting appearance in court in connection with defrauding
Parliament's travel voucher system. Full Article in The Star (24 June
2005)
'Many politicians
benefited from bribes'
Many more
politicians and senior civil servants from the arms industry
are believed to have benefited from bribes paid by Europe's
arms manufactures in bid to secure a stake in the South
African arms deal. This is a view which Richard Young - a
bidder who is now suing the government for R149-million after
unfairly losing out to ADS, the French arms giant's
(Thomson-CSF) subsidiary where Schabir Shaik had a 10% stake -
and Independent Democrats leader Patricia de Lille, share. De
Lille is known to have raised the initial alarm in parliament
about corruption in the arms deal. According a report by
Alameen
Templeton, while Young called for the re-opening of
the arms deal investigations de Lille urged 'the government to
protect the whistle-blowers who first approached her with
their concerns." Full Article in The Star (15 June
2005)
Massive Denel 'kickback'
probe
Details of a
Scorpions criminal investigations into an alleged R100-million
bribe which the South African arms parastal, Denel, paid to a
Saudi Arabian agent in bid to sell artillery systems worth
about $1.4-billion (R8, 6-million) to the Saudis have emerged
following "a desperate legal battle by Denel's Saudi agent to
prevent the Scorpions from gaining access to his Swiss banking
records." According to Mail&Guardian's Sam
Sole and Stefaans Brümmer
the Scorpions want to know if this advance has
flowed to South Africa in the form of kickbacks, with former
directors and officials of Denel, the late defense minister
Joe Modise, the African National Congress and ANC fundraiser
Yusuf Surtee, named as possible recipients. The Scorpions
application to the Swiss bank authorities, where the
R100-million was deposited (in the account of Saudi agent Esam
Hakeem), claims that there is "evidence under oath to the
effect that some of the funds paid as 'commitment' fees might
have found their way back into the Republic of South Africa as
a 'kickback' to some official of Denel and/or to some other
parties (presently unknown)."
Full Article in
Mail&Guardian (15 April
2005)
Senior Scorpion
probed
The Mail & Guardian has
revealed that head of the Scorpion's Operations Unit Jeffrey
Ledwaba is being investigated in connection with allegations
of the plundering of more than R600 000 earmarked for the
payment of informants. (The NPA's 2003/4 annual report shows
that more than R4, 5-m had been spent on informers). According
to a report by Matuma
Letsoalo and Wisani wa ka Ngobeni
National Director of Public Prosecutions, Vusi
Pikoli has put Ledwaba on "special leave" pending the outcome
of the probe. The Ledwaba incident comes in the wake of the
revelation that the Public Service Commission was probing
Marion Sparg, CEO in Pikoli's office, for tendering
irregularities as well as the suspension and subsequent arrest
of former deputy director of Public Prosecutions, Cornwell
Tshavhungwa for allegedly accepting bribes from senior
officials at the Mpumalanga Economic Empowerment Corporation.
Full Article in the Mail &
Guardian (May 13 to 19
2005)
Judge in Scorpions probe
linked to arms deal
Because of her
connubial ties to businessman Siza Khampepe - "director of
Kgorong Investment Holdings, an empowerment partner of Reutach
Radar Systems, which got a R220-million slice of the arms
deal" - the appointment of High Court Judge Sisi Khampepe to
probe the future of the Scorpions has raised concerns about a
possible conflict of interest that could cloud her judgments.
A Sunday Times'
report by Simpiwe Piliso reveals
that attorney Julekha Mohamed, a former legal adviser of
Deputy President Jacob Zuma, as well as a business partner of
Shamin "Chippy" Shaik, the former head of Defence
acquisitions, and his brother Younis, are co-directors with
Judge Khampepe's husband at Kgorong. In addition to testifying
as a defense witness for Schabir Shaik, Mohamed also
represented Mo Shaik, a Foreign Affairs official, and former
Transport Minister Mac Maharaj, at the Hefer Commission of
Inquiry into whether the former Director of Prosecutions,
Bulelani Ngcuka, was an apartheid spy. Presidential spoken
Bheki Khumalo commented that Judge Khampepe is unlikely to
allow personal and financial matters to interfere with her
work and ultimately also has her" own reputation to
protect."
Full Article in
the Sunday Times (03 April
2005)
Provincial
Administration Van Schalkwyk knew about
R300 000 from Agusta, court
told
Allegations
that former leader of the now defunct New National Party
(NNP), Marthinus van Schalkwyk, had approved a R300 000
donation to party funds by the Italian estate magnate Count
Ricardo Agusta have emerged in the corruption trial of former
Western Cape premier, Peter Marais, and former environment
affairs MEC David Malatsi. Both Marais and Malatsi stand
accused of accepting a R400 000 bribe from Agusta, which
gained him the permission to develop a golf estate in an area
deemed to be ecologically sensitive. Melanie Gosling reports
that the Bellville regional court also heard for the first
time that Marais wrote a suppliant letter to Agusta 'giving
him the banking details of the NNP and thanking him in
"anticipation of any donation" to party funds.'
Full Articles
in The Herald (May 18
2005)
and
Cape Times (May 19 2005)
Scorpions investigating
bus mogul: Fakude-Nkuna probed on R120m
fraud
Already under
investigation by the Scorpions for alleged fraud and
corruption at the Mpumalanga Economic Empowerment Corporation
(MEEC) and her name repeatedly featuring in the Schabir Shaik
corruption trial, "[armaments] and transport mogul Nora
Fakude-Nkuna is at the centre of a new R120-million fraud and
corruption investigation into Mpumalanga's biggest bus company
[Buscor]." City Press'
Zinkie Sithole and Justin Arenstein report
that the Scorpions accuse Buscor of "grossly [overstating]
passenger numbers in reports to government subsidy scheme
between 1997 and 2003, using inflated reports to defraud the
taxpayer of an estimated R120 million." Computer records,
hard-drives, documents, receipts and financial records from
Buscor have been seized following the Scorpions pre-dawn raids
on Fakude-Nkuna's private offices. The raid might have been
"based on an independent KMPG audit of traffic volumes and
passenger numbers, which found that Buscor was over-claiming
on government subsidies for rural passengers by an average of
R1, 7-million per month." Full Article in City Press (03 April
2005)
Premier 'protecting her
own'?
Commenting on
the suspension of Vusi Menzelwa, chief financial officer in
the Eastern Cape's provincial agricultural department,
regional secretary of the National Union of Metalworkers of
South Africa (Numsa), Irvin Jim, has claimed that the event
"bolstered evidence that "[Premier] Nosimo Balindlela is using
the state against particular comrades under the pretext of
fighting corruption."" Menzelwa's suspension, according to
Mail & Guardian's
Vicki Robinson, relates to an order he issued, to
the effect that "state financial support for a controversial
agriculture empowerment deal called Kangela be put on hold,
[as the deal was still] being investigated by the Scorpions
for corruption." The Eastern Cape government however has
continued financing the deal despite the arrest of key
individuals implicated in the alleged graft related to
Kangela. The deal became suspect when former Eastern Cape
agriculture minister, Max Mamase, ordered his department to
transfer R15, 68-million to make possible "the acquisition of
a 49% share of [wealthy farm owner Norman] Benjamin's farms by
an empowerment trust called Kangela." The Public Finance
Management Act prohibits such as a move when a chief financial
officer of a provincial department has not authorised
it.
Full Article in
the Mail&Guardian (08 April
2005)
Corruption commission
fails to fly
Opposition
political parties as well as the Grahamstown-based Public
Service Accountability Monitor have voiced serious concerns
regarding the apparent failure of the Pillay Commission of
Inquiry into the finances of the Eastern Cape provincial
administration to get off the ground. The three-person
commission was launched on April 11 after receiving a
six-month mandate from Balindlela to examine the provincial
government's finances. According to Tabelo Timse's report
opposition parties felt extremely pessimistic about the
progress of the commission, citing various reasons including
the idea that the commission was just a political move because
were it to prove effective, the Premier's position would be
compromised. This is reportedly due to the fact that the
investigation's terms of reference dictate that it goes as far
back as 1994 including the time when Balindlela was the MEC of
Education.
Full Article in
The Herald (June 10
2005)
Anything rotten in health
MEC's office? - No house, so MEC lives in
hotels
Rumours
alleging that KwaZulu-Natal health MEC Peggy Nkonyeni has
spent significant sums of state funds on treating herself, her
entourage and occasionally her family members, to luxury stays
in expensive hotels have emerged following the revelation that
she had no house. City
Press' Wonder Hlongwa lists a host of other
corruption allegations against Nkonyeni, including contracting
a company (Icebo Developers) linked to a family member, which
supplied and distributed R1-million worth of food parcels
including at functions she addresses." Nkonyeni refused to
comment on these allegations as she "does not deal with issues
of administration." Full Article in City Press (17 March
2005)
Angry Skwatsha responds to
allegations of corruption
Western Cape
Public Works and Transport MEC Mcebisi Skwatsha has reacted an
accusation that he had signed tender documents for part of
City of Cape Town security contract (valued at R50
million-a-year) on behalf of Jama Security Services cc.
Skwatsha claims to have resigned as a member of Jama and has
proclaimed that 'he had not benefited from illegal activities
and had not signed tender documents for Jama after he had
resigned from the Corporation.' Skwatsha had also been accused
by the DA of failing to declare his Jama interests to the
provincial adminstration. Babalo Ndenze reports that 'the DA
has called on premier Ebrahim Rasool to appoint a commission
of inquiry to look into the allegations against Skwatsha' - a
proposition which he had rejected on the grounds that it was
unnecessary.
Full Article in
the Cape Times (May 27
2005)
Top official arrested for
fraud
Scorpions
spokesperson Lucinda Moonieya has announced that chief
director of the Free State education department, Johannes
Khoarai, as well as businesswoman Karabo Bahumi, have been
arrested on charges of fraud and corruption in the award of
tenders. This follows a Scorpions' investigation, which
revealed that Khoarai had borrowed R300 000 from Bahumi, and
in order to settle this debt he was key in awarding tenders to
Bahumi's company, KBM Services, which was the preferred
bidder, among 153 contenders, to distribute learner support
material in four of the five designated districts. This was
despite the fact that the company did not score the highest
points in the bidding process. A review of the recommendation
in favor of KBM services revealed a number of discrepancies,
'including inconsistencies in reasons for disqualifying other
bidding companies.' Full Article in News24 (26 June
2005)
Local
Government Top city official - 'God
of Hillbrow' -'sought
bribes'
Operations
planning control manager in the Johannesburg city council's
Department of Development Planning, Transportation and
Environment, Allan Wheeler, is accused of harassing city
officials, property owners and close associates in bid to
intimidate them to comply with his solicitations for bribes.
Wheeler is claimed to threaten victims with closing down their
business, demolishing their buildings or terminating their
jobs should they not co-operate with his demand for bribes.
The Star's Christina
Gallagher reports that Wheeler engages in this
activity in his capacity as an investigator of violations of
town planning and a police reservist at the Hillbrow police
station. Wheeler, it is stated in an affidavit, made racist
remarks including claims that "I am the God of Hillbrow..I
will enforce the by-laws because every black man is a criminal
and every black women is a p rostitute." One of the
complainants against Wheeler include Daniel Burger the deputy
sheriff of Johannesburg East.
Full Article in
The Star 23 April
2005
DA fires West Coast mayor
for misleading inquiry
Executive
mayor of West Coast district municipality Hendrick "Pottie"
Potgieter has been sacked following evidence 'that he may have
misled a commission of inquiry into allegations that he made
corrupt use of municipal funds.' This was a swift about-turn
from the Democratic Alliance's (DA) earlier decision to clear
Potgieter of all fraud charges on the basis that there was no
evidence of corruption and maladministration. Karen Breytenbach
reports that Potgieter's dismissal followed an SABC
exposè where it emerged that Potgieter and his two colleagues,
municipal manager Wessel Rabbets and municipal director of
finances Buks Koekemoer, had withheld certain information from
a Department of Local Government and Housing commission. This
had been set up to investigate Potgieter's use of a municipal
credit card to the tune of R300 000, for an overseas trip for
his wife, Marie. Full Article in Cape Times (June 29
2005)
DA claims Plett municipal
manager misused public funds for personal
use
Plettenberg
Bay municipal manager, George Seitisho, has been the target of
a corruption, fraud and theft allegation involving the abuse
of a 'municipal credit card to buy personal items worth R89
000 and making cash withdrawals of R52 000.' The complaint,
which the Democratic Alliance (DA) Plettenberg Bay councilor
Wichardt Brummer had launched, was not denied. According to a
report by Melanie
Gosling, 'Seitisho and members of the municipality
admit[ed] to the misuse of public funds for personal benefit'
but with the qualification that the money had been repaid. The
DA's affidavit followed an auditor-general's report that found
Plettenberg's Bay's Bitou Municipality to be 'effectively
bankrupt' due to overpaid councilors, the fact that the
council's fixed assets of R188 million were not verifiable,
and the absence of internal auditing
processes.
Full Article in
Cape Times (May 12
2005)
Emfuleni suspends
councillor over allegations of
corruption
A forensic
report following an investigation by forensic auditors
Ramathe/Fivaz into fraud and corruption in the Emfuleni
municipality, Gauteng, has fingered a councillor in the
municipality "who allegedly used his influence and position to
write off council debt amounting to R500 000 related to his
business." According to City Press' Caiphus Kgosana the
report states that the councillor had been "colluding with
certain officials within the revenue department of the
municipality to write off the debts." The council has since
been suspended pending a disciplinary
hearing. Full Article in City Press (10 April
2005)
Industry Whistle blower sues
transport agency over his
contract
Khabi Mpato,
ex-chief executive officer of the graft-ridden Cross-Border
Road Transport Agency (CBRTA) has been a victim of unfair
dismissal following blowing the whistle on corruption within
the board of 'the government agency responsible for regulating
road travel between South Africa and its neighboring
countries.' Just six months into the job, Mpato had quickly
'established that the board had deliberately collapsed the
management and reporting structures of the public entity.
Malose Monana
reports that Mpato, who is now suing the agency for
refusing to disburse the full unfair dismissal award due to
him, has not had another job since the sacking two years ago.
Mpato had channeled his grievances to various bodies,
including late Transport Minister Dullah Omar, the national
treasury, the auditor general, the public protector, and the
media - all to no avail. He has now approached the directorate
for serious economic offences as a last resort.
Full Article in Cape Times (15 May
2005)
What's R850m between
friends?
Imperial's
latest proposed BEE (Black Economic Empowerment) deal has
raised questions of potential conflicts of interest following
the report that the managing director of the Airports Company
of South Africa (ACSA), Monhla Hlahla and non-executive ACSA
director Lulu Gwagwa were the main participants. Citizens Julius Cobbet
points out that "[t]he vast majority of Imperial's
car rental business is conducted at airports [and that]
Imperial is a major stakeholder in Tourvest, which has the
concession for retail outlets in airports around the country."
Furthermore ACSA is reported to have spent R850m in operating
expenses during it 2003 financial year, benefiting two of at
least six high-profile organisations on whose board Hlahla
sat. This contravened the King II report on corporate
governance, which prohibits a non-executive director from
being "a significant supplier to, or customer of the company
or group." Acsa's manager of communications, Solomon Makgale,
has dismissed these allegations "as devoid of truth with a
malicious intent."
Full Article in
Citizen (21 April
2005)
Grant scam: Scorpions name
four attorneys
A Scorpions
affidavit tabled before the Grahamstown Court late last year
details a sophisticated scam involving lawyers using "touts"
to recruit people who were claiming state benefits, to be
their clients. The affidavit contains the names of four
attorneys and their firms who are implicated in the elaborate
scheme that reportedly "saw them earn some R20-million in fees
from dubious lawsuits." The Herald's Bongani Siqoko
reports that "concerns about the influx of civil
applications instituted against [the department of Social
Development] by the attorneys [as well as] the attorneys' high
bills for services rendered to the ["touts"]" sparked the
Scorpions investigation.
Full Article in
the Herald (07 April
2005)
Telkom secretly probed top
bosses
City Press is
in possession of a copy of the findings of a report, which
reveals that two of Telkom's senior executive members, Mandla
Ngcobo and Thapelo Petje, have been subject to a clandestine
investigation relating to alleged corruption over the awarding
of a R100m tender. Malose
Monama reports that Telkom's former executive of
security Brian Manning had hired a private investigations
company, Associated Intelligence Network, whose report found
no basis for the allegation that Ngcobo and Petje 'offered to
assist a company bidding for a lucrative Telkom tender to
unseat its rival.' The Telkom board has persuaded one of the
executives, who offered to resign as a result of the
investigation, to retain his
position. Full Article in City Press (19 June
2005)
Social
Justice Welfare: How 'ghosts'
claimed R2, 75m in grants
Following a
tip-off from a whistleblower the Scorpions have swooped on
Roliene Whitehouse, system administrator at the Johannesburg
offices of the Social Development Department from where she
allegedly fleeced R2, 75-million by creating - from December
1994 to September 2004 - "beneficiaries using ID numbers,
names and addresses of dead people, people who did not exist,
and people who had never applied for social grants, and then
induced the department to pay a monthly social grant to these
fictitious beneficiaries." The Star's Jonathan Ancer
further adds that an audit comparing the
government's databases with the recipients of government
salaries, grants and pensions has identified 37 000 civil
servants who potentially "helped themselves to billions of
rands worth of grants meant for children, the disabled and the
elderly."
Full Article in
Star (07 April 2005)
Welfare: 'Corruption and
chaos' at govt refugee
centre
The Home
Affairs refugee office in Rosettenvile, Johannesburg, is
reported to be in a serious state of disorder due to delays in
the processing of applications that result in "hundreds of
refugees spending nights on the pavement, waiting for
officials to process applications." According to Citizen's Steven Motale
the delays are deliberately engineered by Home
Affairs Officials and officers from a private security company
brought in to keep order in queue, "who help refugees jump the
queue for a R500 bribe." Nkosani Sibuyi, Home Affairs
spokesman, however "attributed the delay to "lack of capacity"
and the fact that the department was transforming its Refugee
Affairs Unit." Full Article in Citizen (07 April
2005)
Housing: RDP housing
scandal erupts
A City Press
survey on South Africa's housing-provision machinery has
identified a number of obstacles facing the construction of
low-cost houses, including "corruption, sub-standard
workmanship, no adherence to legislation and policy
frameworks, misallocations of units, under-expenditure of
allocated budgets and crime-related incidents by officials and
businesspeople." City
Press' Makhudu Sefara, Mandla Zulu, Russel Molefe, Mphumzi
Zuzile. Matefu Mokoena, Dan Dhlamini and AENS
indicate that these problems have resulted in the
roll-over of more than R320 million in five provinces:
Northwest (R155, 9 million), Free State (R81 million), Limpopo
(R56, 8 million), Eastern Cape (R26 million), and Mpumalanga
(R8, 5 million). The role-over has meant that nearly "20 000
houses that were supposed to have been built during the last
financial year were not erected [and] as a result, many
beneficiaries who should have received their houses long ago
still face an agonising wait in their makeshift
houses." Full Article in City Press (10 April
2005)
Welfare: Banks agree to
help state stamp out social grant
fraud
Social
Security Agency CEO Fezile Makiwane has announced to
Parliament that SA's top banks have agreed to help the social
development department stamp out its endemic social grant
scams, which Social Development Minister Zola Skweyiya
estimate to cost about R1, 5bn annually. According to a report
by Tamar Kahn,
the banks' preliminary investigation revealed that R60m lay
unclaimed in bank accounts in the Eastern Cape, which raises
concern as 'it was unlikely that poor people genuinely
entitled to social assistance would leave untapped funds in
their accounts.
Full Article in
Business Day (23 June
2005)
Welfare: PE doctor, two
women nabbed for grant fraud
A Scorpions'
pre-dawn raid, which was part of the social development
department's continuing Operation Social Security Grant,
netted Adekunile Matthew Fagbuyi, a foreign doctor with three
different passports who is accused of 'helping patients
fraudulently claim state disability grants.' Fagbuyi, who has
appeared in a New Brighton Court in Port Elizabeth in the
Eastern Cape, together with two women from an informal
settlement in the area, has been denied bail as he might skip
the country. According to a report by Sipho Masondo the
Scorpions confiscated disability grant forms, eleven identity
books and medical documents from the doctor's practice in
Kleinskool.
Full Article in
The Herald (May 20
2005)
Housing: Metro hits back
over AG report on housing
In what has
been a long-waited response to the damning Auditor General
report on irregularities in the Nelson Mandela Metro's housing
programme, the metro has lashed out at the AG's report
accusing it of 'not constituting an audit in terms of
generally accepted government auditing standards.' While
acknowledging irregularities in the filling in of housing
subsidy forms, the municipality 'washed its hands of
responsibility for employees who might have fraudulently
applied for housing subsidies to which they were not entitled.
Max Mamase
reports that the AG report alleged that the metro,
among other things, did not follow tender procedures in three
major housing contracts, thus sparking concerns of possible
conflicts of interest.
Full Article in
The Herald (27 May
2005)
Crime and
justice Police: Probe into 'dirty'
cops: Police captain comes under
investigation
Gauteng
Provincial police authorities, as well as the Sunday Star, are
in possession of the identities of a police captain, his three
alleged home affairs and two police accomplices, and a
Burundian fugitive, who constitute an extortion syndicate that
targets refugees. Michael
Schmidt reports that a Johannesburg SAPS [South
African Police Service] task team has taken sworn affidavits
from a Burundian refugee couple, Nester Niyonzima and his
wife, whom the syndicate fleeced of the equivalent of R74 000.
Masquerading as an Interpol Agent, the policeman captain and
syndicate kingpin allegedly forged "Interpol warrants claiming
Niyonzima was wanted for stealing 149 million Burundian Francs
from his Bank in Burundi, and that his wife wanted for
stealing $15 000 from the US-backed NGO in Burundi where she
had worked. However, four sworn affidavits signed by the
prosecutor-general of Burundi declare that the couple was "not
being sought on any charges by the Burundian authorities."
They had in fact fled Burundi in the wake of death threats
after blowing the whistle on a multi-billion dollar Burundian
bank fraud. Full Article in Sunday Star (02
April 2005)
Police: Corrupt Metro cops
arrested
The number of
police officials arrested for corruption has soared to 46 in
just seven months, following the arrest of two more
Johannesburg police officials for corruption. The police were
caught in trap set after a woman reported their attempt to
extort money from her. Fidelia van der Linde
reports that 'of the 56 corrupt officials, 27 were
arrested for reselling goods confiscated from hawkers, and
others for accepting bribes and selling driver's licenses and
roadworthy certificates.' To report corruption within the
Johannesburg metro police one can call 011-490-1703.
Full Article in New24.com (10 June
2005)
Research: Attitudes to
corruption harden while Mbeki gets a big
'yes'
Research
Surveys, a marketing data company, has published results of
its recent survey of South Africans attitudes towards the
trail of Durban businessman Schabir Shaik as well as the arms
and deal. 85 percent of the urban adults interviewed felt that
inquiries into corruption in the arms deal should continue.
Caroline
Hooper-Box reports that a similar study carried out
in January found that 74 percent of the surveyed South
Africans felt that corruption was becoming a way of life. The
recent survey however indicates that this figure has risen to
83 percent. The figure delineating the perception that there
was corruption in senior levels of government likewise shot up
from 79 to 86 percent. Similarly the approval rating of South
African president Thabo Mbeki crept up to 83 percent - a
remarkable increase from the 48 percent recorded in
January.
Full Article in
Sunday Independent (26 June
2005)
Reform: Beefed-up agency
to tackle fraud
A key
three-year deal with the Department of Social Development to
track down rampant fraud and corruption in the department is
set to bring a substantial increase in the size and budget of
the Special Investigating Unit (SIU). Wyndham Hartley reports
that President Thabo Mbeki had issued the SIU with a
proclamation to embark on the investigations "of the payment
and receipt of social assistance or benefits in respect of the
deceased or fictitious persons and /or persons who do not
qualify for such assistance." Government officials and/or
agents "responsible for the administration and payment of
social grants where there have been losses, delays or loss of
control over money" will also be probed. The SIU, which has
recovered R1 billion in the correctional services over the
past three years, will provide the Social Development
Department with 200 investigators over a period of 30 months
to undertake the investigations. Full Article in Business Day (11
April
2005)
Reform: New Agency to
handle grants of payments from April
2006
Social
Development Minister Zola Skweyiya has announced that by April
2006 a new Social Security Agency will take over the function
of grant payments from provinces. To be established in terms
of the South African Social Security Agency Act of 2004, the
Agency is a bid to ' . improve the efficiency and
effectiveness of grant payments', and therefore realize cost
savings in the new financial year. At present governments
monthly social grants bill is R3,7 billion - the annual budget
for the past financial year is R44
billion.
Full Article in
the Daily Dispatch
Reform: Forum plans guide
to beating corruption
The National
Anti-Corruption Forum (NACF) - consisting of government,
business and civil society representatives has embarked on
projects 'to educate South Africans on steps to take when they
encounter corruption in the workplace.' According to Ernest Mabuza this will
include lobbying for the reform of the Protected Disclosures
Act to ensure that whistleblowers are afforded maximum
protection as well as effective implementation of the
Promotion of Access to Information Act. The NACF, acting upon
resolutions of the 2nd National Anti-Corruption Summit held in
April this year, will also produce a user-friendly guide to
the Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act to be
distributed amongst business people and public servants. R5,8m
has been set-aside for the two-year NACF programme, which will
also work toward improved co-ordination among the various
agencies tasked with countering corruption. NACF chair
Minister Geraldine Fraser-Moloketi recognized the recent
release from office of deputy president Jacob Zuma as "an
appropriate response under the circumstances" and welcomed the
resignation of the five Members of Parliament found guilty of
defrauding Parliament's travel
system.
Full Article in
Business Day (27 June
2005)
Reform: Companies face
threat of 20 years on tender
list
In bid to
complement similar moves aimed at closing the net on
white-collar criminals, government is set to introduce a new
public register (in terms of the Prevention and Combating of
Corrupt Activities Act) - to be maintained by the national
treasury and posted on its website - to name and shame
companies found guilty of offences relating to state tenders.
Sanchia Temkin
reports that guilty companies and non-executive
directors and shareholders, who "knowingly participated in
corrupt dealing or ought reasonably to have known that a
tender bid was fraudulent", could remain in the register for
up to 20 years. Consultant to the South African Chamber of
Business, Bill Lacey, views the register of tender defaulters
as an opportunity to "give the private sector "teeth to ensure
that corrupt practices do not take
place."
Full Article in
Business Day (11 April
2005)
Reform: Ramos cracks down
on Transnet corruption, 'consultants'
haven'
In bid to
crack down on fraud and corruption in giant parastatal
Transnets tendering process, CEO Maria Ramos, has introduced a
whistle-blowing system, and amended rules to prevent its
"employees from bidding for company contracts." Businessday's Rob Rose
reports that the parastatal "has been one of the
worst-performing government assets" and had acquired bad
reputation following concerns over conflicts of interest when
"former Spoornet employees successfully landed Transnet
tenders. Ramos, who described Transnet as a company where
"corruption was still an issue", also slammed empowerment
fronting in contracts awarded to outside
companies.
Full Article in
Business Day (08 April 2005)
This months profile
is a person not an institution or a law and is largely based
on an article written by Mphumzi Zuzile in the City Press (10
April 2005):
Mr. Miki
Mbali "I have given up. If you are not
connected to officials or give them bribes your grant will not
be approved." For over a year Mike Mbali (67) has been
traveling to the city of East London to collect his old age
social grant. He however always returns empty handed to his
shack next to a dumping site in Second Creek squatter camp in
East London. He has now given up on trying to claim a grant.
Mbali, a father of seven with severe TB collects recyclable
waste at the rubbish dump to buy a loaf of bread (he earns 10c
of every kilogram of waste collected). Ho |